Patient Experience Summary

Patient feedback reveals a mixed experience across the practice, with notable variation depending on which staff member is encountered. Clinical expertise and compassionate nursing care are frequently praised, with patients appreciating attentive listening, thorough examinations, and reassuring interactions. Reception staff performance is similarly inconsistent, ranging from genuinely helpful and courteous to dismissive and impatient, particularly toward younger patients. The practice environment maintains good cleanliness standards and is generally described as welcoming.

Appointment access remains a significant concern, with patients reporting difficulty securing appointments, lengthy waiting times, and challenges with the booking system. Administrative processes are described as unreliable, with incomplete prescriptions, delayed responses to communications, and the need for persistent follow-up to achieve results. Communication quality varies considerably, with some patients feeling their concerns are not adequately addressed or heard, whilst others report positive engagement.

Since the pandemic, face-to-face appointment availability has become more constrained, with reception staff determining appointment type rather than patient preference. Patients have noted inconsistency in care standards across different clinicians, with some delivering excellent compassionate practice whilst others appear dismissive or lacking in attentiveness. The experience appears largely determined by chance, as there is no option to request specific practitioners.

Appointment

62.15 %
Average

Reception

71.32 %
Great

Cleanliness

78.50 %
Great

Care

66.78 %
Great

Respect

64.92 %
Average

Seen on time

59.87 %
Average

Filter

RE

Ricky E. Google one year ago

Rating

Bad!

Missed callback due to noisy workplace

I don't believe the practice fully appreciates that many patients are employed and working, which makes callback systems challenging. If you're in a loud workplace, it's easy to miss a call when they ring back, and you end up losing your appointment slot.

Idle Medical Centre

one year ago

Sorry our system doesn't work for you but it is the best way we can deal with the level of demand. You can ask for the call back to be after you finish work as we are calling back until 18.00. We also offer evening and Saturday face 2 face appointments at Idle, Moorside and Windhill Green.

More Info
PW

Patrycja W. Google 2 years ago

Rating

Bad!

Felt unheard during appointment with little sympathy

I had a disappointing experience with one particular clinician at this practice. I felt there was a lack of professionalism and genuine engagement during my consultation, despite having significant health concerns. While the receptionist was pleasant and helpful over the phone, I found the clinical interaction fell short of the compassion and attentiveness I would expect from a healthcare professional in this role. The other staff members at the practice have been satisfactory, but this particular clinician's approach did not meet my expectations for patient care.

Idle Medical Centre

one year ago

I am sorry you have had a bad experience. Please feel free to contact me if you wish to discuss. Kind Regards, Malcolm MacDonald Practice Manager

More Info
PG

Pauline G. Google 2 years ago

Rating

Poor!

Long waits and repeated calls to reach the practice

I experienced a significant delay in receiving a callback regarding some test results that required clarification. When I initially contacted the practice to arrange a consultation, I was informed the wait would be approximately 48 hours. However, once that timeframe had elapsed without contact, I called back only to be told the actual waiting period was 72 hours. This extended delay felt unnecessarily long compared to what might be experienced in an emergency department setting. I found myself making numerous call attempts before successfully getting through to book an appointment—approximately 75 attempts over a 20-minute window during morning hours. Online booking options appear unavailable, with no appointments showing as accessible through that method. The practice's website information also appears outdated, and while it references a positive rating, this assessment dates back several years and may not reflect current service levels. Since the pandemic, face-to-face appointments have become difficult to access, and telephone interactions have been inconsistent in quality. I do want to acknowledge that the nursing and reception staff have been helpful and professional; I recognise they likely bear the brunt of patient frustration given the accessibility challenges. I have concerns about patients who are less digitally confident, particularly regarding the difficulty in requesting prescriptions by phone. The practice might benefit from implementing separate telephone lines for different services—such as dedicated lines for prescription requests, results enquiries, and appointment bookings—rather than routing all calls through a single line. The stress of navigating this process has been considerable. I'm also curious why the practice's public ratings have not been updated since the earlier assessment, and whether this reflects changes in service delivery standards.

Idle Medical Centre

2 years ago

Dear Pauline, Thank you for your feedback. I am sorry you feel our service has failed you recently. I am Malcolm MacDonald, the Practice Manager. You have raised a number of issues which I will try to address. Following your recent blood test you received a text message asking you to make an appointment with a GP "within 2 weeks". This in itself makes clear that the matter was not urgent. We do try to endeavour to meet our 48hr call-back target but on this occasion we have failed and I apologize for this. The point about going to A&E for a blood test is somewhat spurious, we do not ask you sit and wait in the practice to get your results, simply to be available on your phone. Our phone system is, and always will be, very busy at 08.30. If your reason for calling is not urgent, which yours wasn't, then you are better waiting till a little later (after 10.00) and you will almost certainly get straight through. We are introducing a new phone system later in the year which will eliminate the engaged tone as well as offering a range of other benefits. We have adapted our model of operating to offer a range of appointment types and clinicians including Enhanced Access appointments in evenings and weekends both here and at other local practices. You refer to our CQC rating of "Good" and question its validity. We have had 2 "remote" reviews since 2016 (this was a "physical" review). The last review was summer of 2023 and confirmed our "Good" rating. CQC have limited resources, like all parts of the NHS, and save their physical inspections for those organizations that are more problematic. I hope I have addressed your issues but please feel free to contact me at the practice if there is anything you wish to discuss further. Once again apologies for the issues you have had recently. Kind Regards, Malcolm MacDonald Practice Manager Idle Medical Centre

More Info
JW

Jasmine W. Google 2 years ago

Rating

Bad!

Reception staff were dismissive and unhelpful

The reception staff can be dismissive towards younger patients and parents, often speaking in a condescending manner. They frequently sound impatient when answering calls. Rather than providing the supportive service they should offer, their approach leaves you feeling undervalued. If they are unable to perform their role effectively, they may need to consider alternative employment.

Idle Medical Centre

2 years ago

I am sorry that you feel that Reception staff have not dealt with you well. We try to treat all patients the same. We are often very busy and so staff may have limited time but I would hope that does not lead to rudeness. If you wish to discuss any issues then please feel free to call me. Malcolm MacDonald Practice Manager

More Info
SH

S H. Google 2 years ago

Rating

Excellent!

Prompt appointments and caring staff made all the difference

Excellent team at the front desk and clinical staff. My family members have consistently received timely appointments whenever they've needed care. The administrative team demonstrates helpfulness and understanding, while the clinical practitioners provide comprehensive and compassionate treatment. Much appreciated for the attentive care provided to our family!

Idle Medical Centre

2 years ago

Thank you very much for these lovely words. They are much appreciated. Idle Medical Centre

More Info
JH

Jean H. Google 2 years ago

Rating

Excellent!

Reception staff were friendly and professional

My time at the medical centre has been very positive. I have been managing an ongoing health matter, and throughout this process I have been treated with courtesy and compassion. The front desk team have been outstanding, displaying both warmth and professionalism. The clinical team have similarly provided excellent care, offering comprehensive information that has helped me feel confident and supported.

Idle Medical Centre

2 years ago

Thank you very much for these positive comments. They are much appreciated. Idle Medical Centre

More Info
MS

Mr S. Google 3 years ago

Rating

Excellent!

Felt listened to during my appointment

Had an appointment today with a clinician who was absolutely fantastic. They demonstrated patience and professionalism, and genuinely listened to my concerns. Other healthcare professionals at this practice could benefit from following their example.

Idle Medical Centre

2 years ago

Thank you for these kind words.

More Info
CB

C B. Google 3 years ago

Rating

Excellent!

Helpful staff managing challenging circumstances well

The standard of care provided recently has been commendable, with appreciation extended to the entire team managing their responsibilities under challenging conditions.

Idle Medical Centre

2 years ago

Thank you for these kind words.

More Info
LA

Lyra A. Google 3 years ago

Rating

Great!

Receptionist took time to listen and help

I recently had a pleasant phone interaction with a member of the reception team. Unlike some previous calls where I've felt rushed due to staff being busy, this time the person I spoke with was genuinely kind, patient, and went out of their way to help me. It was a really positive experience😊

Idle Medical Centre

3 years ago

Thank you for these kind comments. They are much appreciated.

More Info
LK

L K. Google 3 years ago

Rating

Excellent!

Phlebotomist made blood test less daunting

I had a blood test today, which is something I find quite anxiety-inducing, particularly given how often I need to have them done. The nursing staff member was absolutely wonderful and really helped to calm my nerves. They were very skilled at the procedure, resulting in minimal bruising, which hasn't always been my experience in the past. I was genuinely grateful for how reassuring and professional they were, as it made a real difference to my overall experience and helped prevent me from becoming distressed.

Idle Medical Centre

3 years ago

Thank you so much for these lovely comments and so glad your experience was so good. I will make Victoria aware. She will be delighted to get such positive feedback. Malcolm MacDonald Practice Manager

More Info
JR

Jane R. Google 4 years ago

Rating

Excellent!

Reception staff made me feel genuinely cared for

Having had occasion to contact the medical centre on several occasions recently, I feel compelled to praise the reception team. They demonstrate genuine care, maintain professionalism, and consistently go the extra mile to help. I spoke with a member of the reception staff today who was an absolute credit to the practice. This is particularly important given that receptionists are often patients' first point of contact. I have also been fortunate to receive treatment from a clinician at the practice.

Idle Medical Centre

3 years ago

Thank you so much for this very kind review. I will make sure that everybody involved is aware of it. It really is much appreciated. Malcolm MacDonald Practice Manager

More Info
DG

Dan G. Google 4 years ago

Rating

Bad!

Felt unheard during shoulder injury appointment

In my experience, the clinician displayed an attitude that made me feel unheard and dismissed. When discussing my shoulder injury, the explanation provided using an inanimate object analogy felt inappropriate and failed to acknowledge the significant difference between mechanical wear and the pain I was experiencing. I felt that my concerns were not properly considered, and I would have appreciated a more attentive approach to understanding my specific needs rather than a superficial acknowledgment before moving on to the next matter.

Idle Medical Centre

3 years ago

We are sorry if you feel you did not get the treatment you wanted. If you want to get in touch to discuss your issues directly then please contact the practice and ask to speak to the Practice Manager.

More Info
DH

David H. Google 5 years ago

Rating

Bad!

Appointment access remains extremely difficult

The service has been disappointing. Obtaining an appointment has become increasingly challenging, particularly since the pandemic, and it is no longer possible to request a specific clinician—instead, availability is determined by reception staff. There have been instances where prescriptions have arrived incomplete. The level of support available has diminished significantly. Despite making multiple attempts to communicate concerns through email and written correspondence, these have not received responses. Given the seriousness of the health matters involved, this lack of engagement has been frustrating. As a result, I have made the decision to change practices and have also raised a complaint with the NHS complaints procedure.

More Info
HH

Helen H. Google 5 years ago

Rating

Excellent!

Friendly staff who really listened to me

Excellent healthcare provider with a professional approach and welcoming team members who are pleasant to communicate with.

Idle Medical Centre

2 years ago

Thank you for these kind words

More Info
C(

Craig (. Google 5 years ago

Rating

Excellent!

Clean surgery with friendly reception staff

The practice maintains high standards of cleanliness, and the team members are consistently pleasant and welcoming.

More Info
RA

Richard A. Google 5 years ago

Rating

Bad!

Scan results weren't properly reviewed beforehand

I had concerns about the quality of care I received. I would recommend that if you attend for imaging procedures, it would be helpful to ensure that relevant medical records are reviewed beforehand.

More Info
AH

Atiq H. Google 5 years ago

Rating

Excellent!

Friendly GP who actually takes time to listen

The clinician at this practice is nothing short of brilliant. My family and I have experienced various health challenges, and the doctor has proven to be friendly, understanding, and knowledgeable. They consistently make time to listen and are always willing to help. An utterly professional healthcare provider.

More Info
EW

Elliott W. Google 6 years ago

Rating

Bad!

Rushed appointments leave little time for listening

I feel that the focus seems to be on processing patients efficiently rather than taking time to understand individual concerns. Over the past decade, I have encountered only one healthcare professional who appeared genuinely interested in understanding my situation and working towards a resolution. I find the experience of contacting this practice for assistance quite frustrating and would prefer to manage difficulties independently.

More Info
SY

Sue Y. Google 6 years ago

Rating

Excellent!

Friendly staff made me feel welcome

An excellent healthcare facility with welcoming team members and highly competent clinicians.

More Info
NT

Nobby T. Google 7 years ago

Rating

Great!

Staff were friendly and helpful throughout

The team here are welcoming and supportive, and the practice has made considerable progress and enhancements during recent times.

More Info

For practice staff

Respond to patient reviews

Monitor satisfaction trends

Generate CQC evidence reports

Claim & Manage Profile
Trusted by GP practices across the UK
Practice Response Rate
66.67%

Shows how often this practice responds to patient reviews and feedback.

About the GP

  • Accepts all feedback, both positive and negative.

Contact Information

  • 01274 771999
  • Idle Medical Centre 440 Highfield Road, Idle Bradford West Yorkshire BD10 8RU

Patient Experience Summary

Patient feedback reveals a mixed experience across the practice, with notable variation depending on which staff member is encountered. Clinical expertise and compassionate nursing care are frequently praised, with patients appreciating attentive listening, thorough examinations, and reassuring interactions. Reception staff performance is similarly inconsistent, ranging from genuinely helpful and courteous to dismissive and impatient, particularly toward younger patients. The practice environment maintains good cleanliness standards and is generally described as welcoming.

Appointment access remains a significant concern, with patients reporting difficulty securing appointments, lengthy waiting times, and challenges with the booking system. Administrative processes are described as unreliable, with incomplete prescriptions, delayed responses to communications, and the need for persistent follow-up to achieve results. Communication quality varies considerably, with some patients feeling their concerns are not adequately addressed or heard, whilst others report positive engagement.

Since the pandemic, face-to-face appointment availability has become more constrained, with reception staff determining appointment type rather than patient preference. Patients have noted inconsistency in care standards across different clinicians, with some delivering excellent compassionate practice whilst others appear dismissive or lacking in attentiveness. The experience appears largely determined by chance, as there is no option to request specific practitioners.

Appointment

62.15 %
Average

Reception

71.32 %
Great

Cleanliness

78.50 %
Great

Care

66.78 %
Great

Respect

64.92 %
Average

Seen on time

59.87 %
Average
Filter

Order By

Rating